The Best Puppy Collars

main image for the best puppy collars

A great puppy collar can make raising your little pups a lot easier. Good collars can keep your dog comfortable, help identify them if they get lost, and even prevent or reduce certain ailments depending on the type of collar. But not every puppy collar will fit your needs (or even your dog), which is why we've made this list of the ones we think are best. Read on and get ready to accessorize your tiny pal in a whole new way.

What to Look For

There were three things a puppy collar had to achieve to get four paws up from us: is the collar easy to adjust for multiple puppy sizes? Does it fit in a way that’s both snug and safe? Finally, does it have a nice aesthetic, and will it increase your puppy’s cuteness even further? Every puppy collar on this list managed to do all of these things and more in a way that left us totally satisfied. Gamuda won our top prize thanks to their collars’ soft material and bright colors. We also loved the effective design qualities and rugged, handsome look of the Roam collar. Keep reading to see which puppy collar will be adorning your canine companion today.

Gamuda Super Soft Puppy Collar

Gamuda Super Soft Puppy Collar

Gentle but firm

This puppy collar provides a cozy touch with a quality fit.
Best Overall

Find on Amazon

A steadfast focus on increasing your little dog’s quality of life makes this our favorite puppy collar. Its soft nylon material and safe yet comfortable hook-and-loop enclosure system will keep your puppy from growing agitated with his new accessory. Plus, twelve bright vibrant colors to choose from ensure you’ll never lose track of your wee friend. Small dogs of all shapes and (relatively tiny) sizes will adore this straightforward puppy collar.  

Pros 

  • Comes in small and medium sizes to account for multiple breeds 
  • Can be ordered with a reflective stripe to increase visual awareness when out and about 
  • Strong enough to survive wear and tear even from rambunctious puppies 

Cons 

  • Newborns may be able to wiggle out of them 

Joytale Soft Reflective Puppy Collar

Joytale Soft Reflective Puppy Collar

Night vision

The reflective elements of this puppy collar make it a boon for safety.
Runner Up

Find on Amazon

You won’t have to worry about walking your puppy at night with the help of this reflective puppy collar. Its reflective threads, woven in vibrant colors, do a great job of making sure your dog will be visible even in the deepest darkness. It also has a quick-release latch system, letting you unhook it swiftly if it gets caught on anything. Night walkers definitely shouldn’t stumble around in the dark when it comes to this excellent puppy collar. 

Pros 

  • Exceptional value for the level of safety it represents 
  • Comes in a tremendous variety of bright, unique colors 
  • Soft and easy to adjust while still being sturdy and difficult to chew through 

Cons 

  • Extra padding can weigh down some more miniature puppies 

Roam Premium Adjustable Heavy-Duty Dog Collar

Roam Premium Adjustable Heavy-Duty Dog Collar

Tough pup

Nothing tops this puppy collar for sheer strength.
Best Design

Find on Amazon

If you need a puppy collar with a bit more grit than the average fare, this is the one for you. Roam combines heavily stitched, double-layered nylon webbing with a rust-free metal buckle to make a collar that even the rowdiest puppy won’t be able to chew off. Luckily, that nylon also has a comfortable feel, so your pup won’t be made to feel like they’re being punished. This puppy collar truly combines the best of both worlds, and we couldn’t be happier about it.  

Pros 

  • Rugged visual design and subtle colors give it a unique look 
  • D-ring is easy to attach your leash to 
  • Surprisingly easy to clean given how tough they are 

Cons 

  • Very heavy and may weigh down smaller or weaker puppies 

Ladoogo Padded Reflective Dog Collar

Ladoogo Padded Reflective Dog Collar

Join together

The leash is as well worth recommending as the puppy collar that comes with it.
Best With Leash

Find on Amazon

A great puppy collar with an excellent leash to go with it is a deal that’s pretty hard to beat. With a double-padded neoprene weave and highly visible reflection effects, it’s perfect for keeping your pup comfy while keeping them safe too. It also has an excellent leash with a foam grip and a tangle-free cord. Those on the market for both a new puppy collar and a new leash too have found their perfect match.  

Pros 

  • Many excellent colors and patterns to choose from  
  • Leash length hits the right balance between letting your dog walk freely and keeping them close 

Cons 

  • Buckle tends to come loose during resizing  

Pupteck Adjustable Soft Mesh Harness Puppy Collar

Pupteck Adjustable Soft Mesh Harness Puppy Collar

The full package

Your dog will look adorable in this puppy collar and harness combo.
Best With Harness

Find on Amazon

Some puppies need a little extra gear, which is where this great harness and puppy collar combo comes in. This wonderfully soft triple threat of leash, harness, and puppy collar packed together ensures your pup will have a safe and cozy time on your walk. Plus, it costs a fraction of what buying all of these items separately would run you. Add in the lightweight air mesh construction of the harness and you have one of our favorite puppy collar deals.  

Pros 

  • Double d-hooks on harness make it nearly impossible for your pup to wriggle loose 
  • Flannel and dotted patterns are adorable, and come in a variety of fun colors 
  • Quick-release features make the set easy to take off when your walk is over 

Cons 

  • Dirt and grime show up rather easily, requiring frequent washing 

Frequently Asked Questions

What safety features should I look for in a puppy collar?

Most if not all collars should have some type of quick-release feature in case your puppy gets the collar caught on something whilst scampering around. And if you take walks at night, getting a puppy collar with reflective material that glows in the dark is practically a necessity.

What’s the best way to clean a puppy collar?

If your puppy collar is made of something like nylon, it should be a simple matter of throwing it in the wash whenever you have the time. Neoprene collars can require a bit more time and elbow grease, but it’s worth it for the combination of comfort and durability they will provide to your puppy.

About the Author

Chris lives in Austin with a very spunky red heeler mix. This pooch has very specific dietary needs and requires lots of attention and exercise, so Chris knows exactly how to search for the best products out there to keep dogs happy. Chris is great at finding dog-friendly items that aren't just the best in their class, but work for the specific needs of different types of dogs as well.

Why Trust Us

DogTime is a leading resource for dog owners & pet lovers. Our goal is to give every dog & pet a happy, healthy home by providing the best advice to owners.